College Quality Assurance and Enhancement Committee (CMVM) Papers | www.committees.ed.ac.uk

College Quality Assurance and Enhancement Committee (CMVM)

Contact us

2025

Date	Agenda	Papers	Notes	Minutes
11 March	Agenda - CQAEC 11th March 2025 (187.9kB)	CQAE 24-25 03 A minutes 21st Jan 2025 UNCONFIRMED (184.3kB) CQAE 24-25 03 B Action status report 21 Jan 2025 (92.4kB)

2024

Date	Agenda	Papers	Notes	Minutes
10 December	Agenda - CQAEC 10th Dec 2024 (144.4kB)	CQAE 24-25 02 A minutes 8th October 2024 UNCONFIRMED (208.8kB) CQAE 24-25 02 B Action status report 8 Oct 2024 (92kB) CQAE 24-25 02 C CMVM Annual QA Report FINAL (200.7kB)
8 October	Agenda - CQAEC 8th May 2024 (148.6kB)	CQAE 24-25 01 A Unconfirmed Minutes 21 May 2024 (177.4kB) CQAE 24-25 01 B Action status report 21 May 2024 (97.1kB) CQAE 24-25 01 C College Quality Assurance and Enhancement Committee ToR 2024-25 (137.1kB) CQAE 24-25 01 D Taught External Examiner Approval Sub-Committee Terms of Reference 2024-25 (130.3kB) CQAE 24-25 01 E Edinburgh Medical School AnnualReport-School2023-24 finalClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 24-25 01 F DBMS annual report 23 24ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 24-25 01 G DCS AnnualReport 2023-24 FINALClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 24-25 01 H 2324 MGPHS finalClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 24-25 01 I 2023-24 RDSVSClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 24-25 01 J Themes arising from 23-24 Annual QA reports (150.9kB) CQAE 24-25 01 K themes arising from cmvm 2023-24 IPRs (133.2kB)
21 May	Agenda - CQAEC 21 May 2024 (136.8kB)	CQAE 23-24 04 A 27 Feb minutes UNCONFIRMED (173.5kB) CQAE 23-24 04 B Action status report (95.1kB) CQAE 23-24 04 C Recognition of Prior Learning (147.6kB) CQAE 23-24 04 D RPL Application and evidence forms CMVM (179.9kB) CQAE 23-24 04 E Medical Education PGT RPL Process (190kB) CQAE 23-24 04 F UG External Examiner Report statistics 2022-23ClosedDocument not published: Personal information the disclosure of which would breach the data protection principles of the Data Protection Act (section 38) CQAE 23-24 04 G EE comments paper UG 2022-23 (223.4kB) CQAE 23-24 04 H PGT External Examiner Report statistics 2022-23ClosedDocument not published: Personal information the disclosure of which would breach the data protection principles of the Data Protection Act (section 38) CQAE 23-24 04 I EE comments paper PGT 2022-23 (225kB)
27 February	Agenda - CQAEC 27th Feb 2024 (141.8kB)	CQAE 23-24 03 A 12th Dec QAEC minutes (179.5kB) CQAE 23-24 03 B Action status report (96.8kB) CQAE 23-24 03 C Ethical Review process summaries from local areasClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE23-24 03 D RCVS-aspa-flow-chartClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE23-24 03 E RDSVS ethics flowchart 2021 1page v4ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions

2023

Date	Agenda	Papers	Notes	Minutes
12 December	Agenda - CQAEC 12 Dec 2023 (162.7kB)	CQAE 23-24 02 A Minutes 19th Sep 2023 UNCONFIRMED (191.2kB) CQAE 23-24 02 B Action status report (95.5kB) CQAE 23-24 02 C SVG Action notes 17th Nov 23 v2ClosedDocument not published: Personal information the disclosure of which would breach the data protection principles of the Data Protection Act (section 38) CQAE 23-24 02 D College QA report FinalClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions
19 September	Agenda - CQAEC 19 Sep 2023 (372.2kB)	CQAE 23-24 01 A UNCONFIRMED minutes 24th May (349.2kB) CQAE 23-24 01 B Action status report (196kB) CQAE 23-24 01 C College Quality Assurance and Enhancement Committee ToR 2023-24 (403.7kB) CQAE 23-24 01 D Taught External Examiner Approval Sub-Committee Terms of Reference 2023-24 (397.4kB) CQAE 23-24 01 E Application of own work declarationClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 23-24 01 F Medical Education annualreport 2022-23(v2)ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 23-24 01 G DBMS Annual quality report 22 23ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 23-24 01 H DCS AnnualReport 2022-23 Final 17 Aug 2023ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 23-24 01 I DMGPHS AnnualReport-DMGPHS-2022-23 21082023ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 23-24 01 J RDSVS AnnualReport-2022-23ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 23-24 01 K -SAQR-SubGroupReport2022-23ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 23-24 01 L Ethical Review process summaries from local areasClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions
24 May	Agenda - CQAEC 24 May 2023 (288.7kB)	CQAE 22-23 04 A Minutes 8th March 2023 DRAFT (338.2kB) CQAE 22-23 04 B UG External Examiner Report statistics 2021-22ClosedDocument not published: Personal information the disclosure of which would breach the data protection principles of the Data Protection Act (section 38) CQAE 22-23 04 C EE comments paper UG 2021-22 (487.5kB) CQAE 22-23 04 D CMVM PGT External Examiner Report statistics 2021-22ClosedDocument not published: Personal information the disclosure of which would breach the data protection principles of the Data Protection Act (section 38) CQAE 22-23 04 E EE comments paper PGT 2021-22 (481.7kB) CQAE 22-23 04 F EE exceptional appointments approved during 2021-22ClosedDocument not published: Personal information the disclosure of which would breach the data protection principles of the Data Protection Act (section 38)
11 January	Agenda - CQAEC 11 Jan 2023 (304.4kB)	CQAE 22-23 02 A Minutes 5 October 2022 UNCONFIRMED (357.2kB) CQAE 22-23 02 B Action status report (200.5kB) CQAE 22-23 02 C CMVM Annual QA Report 2021-22 FINALClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions

2022

Date	Agenda	Papers	Notes	Minutes
5 October	Agenda - CQAEC 5Oct 2022 FINAL (311.4kB)	CQAE 22-23 01 A Minutes 25 May 2022 DRAFT (338.7kB) CQAE 22-23 01 B Action status report 21-22 (283.1kB) CQAE 22-23 01 C College Quality Assurance and Enhancement Committee ToR 2022-23 (404.7kB) CQAE 22-23 01 D Taught EE Approval Sub-Committee ToR 2022-23 (397.3kB) CQAE 22-23 01 E EMS QA report 2021-22ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 22-23 01 F DBMS QA Report 2021-22ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 22-23 01 G DCS QA Report 21-22ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 22-23 01 H MGPHS QA report 21-22ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 22-23 01 I RDSVS 2021.2022 FinalClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 22-23 01 J SAQR-SubGroupReport2021-22 (504.5kB)
25 May	Agenda - CQAEC 25 May 2022 FINALv2 (307.6kB)	CQAE 21-22 05 A Minutes 9 March 2022 UNCONFIRMED (339.1kB) CQAE 21-22 05 B Action status report 9 March 2022 (284.3kB) CQAE 21-22 05 C DoQ update Medical Education (323.6kB) CQAE 21-22 05 D DoQ Biomedical Sciences (316.2kB) CQAE 21-22 05 E DoQ update Clinical Sciences (316.2kB) CQAE 21-22 05 F DoQ update MolGenPop (320.4kB) CQAE 21-22 05 G DoQ update Vet School (1.1MB) CQAE 21-22 05 I EE comments paper UG 2021-21 (475kB) CQAE 21-22 05 J EE comments paper PGT 2021-21 (473.1kB)
9 March	Agenda - CQAEC 9 March 2022 - updated (486.9kB)	CQAE 21-22 04 A Minutes 12 Jan 2022 UNCONFIRMED (412.3kB) CQAE 21-22 04 B Action status report 9 Jan 2021 (284.6kB) CQAE 21-22 04 C Remitting actions from Annual Quality Reports - v2ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 21-22 04 D UG External Examiner Report statistics 2021-22ClosedDocument not published: Personal information the disclosure of which would breach the data protection principles of the Data Protection Act (section 38) CQAE 21-22 04 E CMVM PGT External Examiner Report statistics 2020-21 V2ClosedDocument not published: Personal information the disclosure of which would breach the data protection principles of the Data Protection Act (section 38) CQAE 21-22 04 F EE exceptional appointments approved during 2020.21 FINALClosedDocument not published: Personal information the disclosure of which would breach the data protection principles of the Data Protection Act (section 38) CQAE 21-22 04 G C non-credit bearing provision Annual Monitoring templates (284.7kB) CQAE 21-22 04 H Draft CPD Annual monitoring template v2 (867.2kB) CQAE 21-22 04 I Draft MOOC Annual monitoring template -v2 (863.1kB)
13 January	Agenda - CQAEC 12 January 2022 (484.4kB)	CQAE 21-22 03 A Minutes 10 Nov 2021 UNCONFIRMED (382.5kB) CQAE 21-22 03 B Action status report 10 Nov 2021 (281.9kB) CQAE 21-22 03 C CMVM QA report 2020.21 (Nov 2021) FINAL (934kB) CQAE 21-22 03 D EDI inclusion in course approval (493kB)

2021

Date	Agenda	Papers	Notes	Minutes
10 November	Agenda - CQAEC 10 Nov 2021 FINAL (374.2kB)	CQAE 21-22 02 A Minutes 22 Sep 2021 DRAFT (353.8kB) CQAE 21-22 02 B Action status report 28 May 2021 (202.8kB) CQAE 21-22 02 C Selecting ZJE UG Student Representatives using a lottery (894.7kB) CQAE 21-22 02 D Outstanding Examples of L T practice - nominations from CMVM (467.4kB)
22 September	Agenda - CQAEC 22 Sep 2021 DRAFT (311.5kB)	CQAE 21-22 01 A Minutes 28 May 2021 UNCONFIRMED (348.8kB) CQAE 21-22 01 B College Quality Assurance and Enhancement Committee ToR 2021-22 (404.1kB) CQAE 21-22 01 C Taught External Examiner Approval Sub-Committee Terms of Reference 2021-22 (396kB) CQAE 21-22 01 D EMS SAQR 2020-2021ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 21-22 01 E DBMS Annual report 20 21 finalClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 21-22 01 F DCS QA 21ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 21-22 01 G DMGPHS Annual Quality Report 2021 final 20082021ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 21-22 01 H SAQR-RDSVS 2020.2021 FinalClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 21-22 01 J Remitting actions from Annual Quality Reports - DRAFT (397.4kB) CQAE 21-22 01 K PaperA-UniversityLevelActionsUpdate (472.8kB) CQAE 21-22 01 L university-of-edinburgh-elir-outcome-21 (172kB) CQAE 21-22 01 M IPR Clinical Education - Final ReportClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions
28 May	Agenda - CQAEC 28 May 2021 FINAL (304.3kB)	CQAE 20-21 05 A Minutes 28 April 2021 (569.1kB) CQAE 20-21 05 B Action status report 28 May 2021 (193.1kB) CQAE 20-21 05 C CQAEC note from MVM SMT april 2021ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 20-21 05 D StudentVoicePolicy (955.6kB) CQAE 20-21 05 E StudentVoicePolicy-EqIA (429.7kB) CQAE 20-21 05 F IPR OHS FinalReport (348.3kB)
28 April	Agenda - CQAEC 28 April 2021 (498kB)	CQAE 20-21 04 A Minutes 3 March 2021 UNCONFIRMED (547.5kB) CQAE 20-21 04 B Action status report 3 March 2021 (198.9kB) CQAE 20-21 04 C Remitting actions from Annual Quality Reports - FINAL with updates addedClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 20-21 04 D CSTO Moderation Guide 2021 22 (835.2kB) CQAE 20-21 04 E CSTO Moderation Record Single Marking template (432kB) CQAE 20-21 04 F CSTO Moderation Record Double Marking template (440kB) CQAE 20-21 04 G CMVM PGT External Examiner Report statistics 2019-20 (520kB) CQAE 20-21 04 H EE comments paper PGT 2019-20 (478.5kB)
3 March	Agenda - CQAEC 3 March 2020 (507kB)	CQAE 20-21 03 A Minutes 9 Deccember 2020 UNCONFIRMED (585.8kB) CQAE 20-21 03 B Action status report 9 Dec 2020 (196.7kB) CQAE 20-21 03 C BMS Annual report 19 20ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 20-21 03 D UG External Examiner Report statistics 2019-20ClosedDocument not published: Personal information the disclosure of which would breach the data protection principles of the Data Protection Act (section 38) CQAE 20-21 03 E EE comments paper UG 2019-20 (471.8kB)

2020

Date	Agenda	Papers	Notes	Minutes
9 December	Agenda - CQAEC 9 December 2020 FINAL (505.2kB)	CQAE 20-21 02 A Minutes 14 October 2020 UNCONFIRMED (544kB) CQAE 20-21 02 B Action status report 14 Oct 2020 (200.4kB) CQAE 20-21 02 C EMS Medical Education annual report Nov2020ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 20-21 02 D BMS Annual report 19 20ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 20-21 02 E DCS QA20 FINALClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 20-21 02 F DMGPHS annualreport2020 final 19112020ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 20-21 02 G RDSVS QAE School Annual Monitoring Report 2019.2020ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 20-21 02 H College of Medicine and Veterinary Medicine Annual QA Report 2019.20 FINAL v2ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 20-21 02 I College oversight of courses FINAL (640.3kB)
14 October	Agenda - CQAEC 14 October 2020 FINAL (514.5kB)	CQAE 20-21 01 A Minutes 9 June 2020 UNCONFIRMED (325.9kB) CQAE 20-21 01 B Minutes 2 September 2020 UNCONFIRMED (323.8kB) CQAE 20-21 01 C Action status report 9 June and 2 Sep 2020 (211.1kB) CQAE 20-21 01 D College Quality Assurance and Enhancement Committee ToR 2021-21 DRAFT (404.8kB) CQAE 20-21 01 E UniversityLevelActions (468kB) CQAE 20-21 01 F Programme Closures and Major Changes-Final-11 May 2020ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions CQAE 20-21 01 G External Examiner Nomination form with comments (554.8kB) CQAE 20-21 01 H ems year on response may2020update (184.5kB)
9 June	Agenda - CQAEC 9 June 2020 FINAL (312.4kB)	19-20 CQAE 028 Minutes 11 March 2020 UNCONFIRMED (488.9kB) 19-20 CQAE 029 Action status report 11 March 2020 FINAL (281.7kB) 19-20 CQAE 030 1920ProgrammeAnnualMonReport (627.1kB) 19-20 CQAE 031 1920SchoolAnnualMonReport (610.1kB) 19-20 CQAE 032 1920CollegeAnnualMonReport (593.7kB) 19-20 CQAE 033 CMVM External Examiners - exceptional appointments approved during 2019.20 FINAL (436.2kB) 19-20 CQAE 034 CMVM Cross-College overview of SSLC remits (674.1kB)
11 March	Agenda - CQAE 11 March 2020 FINAL (296.4kB)	19-20 CQAE 023 Minutes 14 Jan 2019 UNCONFIRMED (349.5kB) 19-20 CQAE 024 Action status report 14 Jan 2020 FINAL (212.9kB) 19-20 CQAE 025 CMVM PGT External Examiner Report statistics 2018-19 FINALClosedDocument not published: Personal information the disclosure of which would breach the data protection principles of the Data Protection Act (section 38) 19-20 CQAE 026 EE comments paper PGT 2018-19 FINAL (470.4kB) 19-20 CQAE 027 College oversight of course approval and changes (525.3kB)
14 January	Agenda - CQAE 14 Jan 2020 FINAL (311.2kB)	19-20 CQAE 018 Minutes 14 October 2019 UNCONFIRMED (485.2kB) 19-20 CQAE 020 CMVM - College QA Report 2018.19 Final (782.2kB) 19-20 CQAE 021 CMVM UG External Examiner Report statistics 2018-19ClosedDocument not published: Personal information the disclosure of which would breach the data protection principles of the Data Protection Act (section 38) 19-20 CQAE 022 EE comments paper UG 2018-19 (469.9kB)

2019

Date	Agenda	Papers	Notes	Minutes
14 October	Agenda - CQAE 14 October 2019 FINAL (342kB)	19-20 CQAE 01 Minutes 12 June 2019 UNCONFIRMED (484.7kB) 19-20 CQAE 02 CQAE Terms of Reference 2019-20 (400.1kB) 19-20 CQAE 03 Taught External Examiner Approval Sub-Committee Terms of Reference 2019-20 (393.3kB) 19-20 CQAE 04 EMS Medical EducationClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 19-20 CQAE 05 DBMS QAE report 2018 19ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 19-20 CQAE 06 DCS 2018-19ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 19-20 CQAE 07 DMGPHS 2018-19ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 19-20 CQAE 08 RDSVS 2018.19ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 19-20 CQAE 09 SQAC-SubGroupReport2018-19 (650.5kB) 19-20 CQAE 10 SAQR-GoodPractice (651.2kB) 19-20 CQAE 11 Annual School QA Reports - common themes and GP (624.2kB) 19-20 CQAE 12 SSLC College mtg 20190829 - actions about SSLC meetings (524.3kB) 19-20 CQAE 13 SSLCGuidance Aug19 - DRAFT for consultation on principles (645.5kB) 19-20 CQAE 14 PPR Research 14wk response (140.9kB) 19-20 CQAE 15 Year on TPR response BMS FINAL (741.8kB) 19-20 CQAE 16 R(D)SVS External Examiner Communications Process - UG - July 2019 (157.5kB) 19-20 CQAE 17 R(D)SVS External Examiner Communications Process - PGT - July 2019 (101.4kB)
12 June	Agenda - CQAE 12 June 19 (392.1kB)	18-19 CQAE 046 Minutes 6 May 2019 UNCONFIRMED (351.2kB) 18-19 CQAE 047 Action status report 6 May 2019 meeting (221.9kB) 18-19 CQAE 048 Non-QAE Committee Actons addressed to College from School Deanery Annual QA reports - updated 4 June 2019ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 049 External Examiner Process (483.4kB) 18-19 CQAE 050 Appendix 1 VTO Process for paper submission May 2019 (78.3kB) 18-19 CQAE 050 Appendix 2 BMS committe approval process 1819 (95.2kB) 18-19 CQAE 050 Good practice tips for BoS 4 June 2019 (518kB) 18-19 CQAE 051 SQAC Providing Summaries of Student Feedback to School Representatives - Pilot update (143.5kB) 18-19 CQAE 052 SQAC Student Staff Liaison Committees (SSLC) escalation of issues - DRAFT (257.4kB) 18-19 CQAE 053 SQAC Studetn staff Liaison Committeess (SSLC) Operational Guidance - DRAFT (529.4kB) 18-19 CQAE 055 PPRMVM FinalReport (257kB)
6 May	Agenda - CQAE 6 May 2019 (264.9kB)	18-19 CQAE 040 Action status report 4 March 2019 meeting (142.6kB) 18-19 CQAE 041 Year-on response Clinical Sciences FINAL 17 December 2018ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 042 EMS 1 Year on response March19ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 043 ELIR2020FinalThemes (266.9kB) 18-19 CQAE 044 SQAC-PrioritiesMidYearUpdate (240.4kB) 18-19 CQAE 045 InternalReviewThemes2017-18 (419.6kB) 18-19 CQAE 054 SQAC update on College Report Actions to the University (241.5kB)

2018

Date	Agenda	Papers	Notes	Minutes
13 December	Agenda - CQAE 13 December 2018 (233.2kB)	18-19 CQAE 023 CQAE Minutes 8 Oct 2018 UNCONFIRMED (330.4kB) 18-19 CQAE 024 Action status report 8 October 2018 meeting (218.3kB) 18-19 CQAE 025 CMVM College QAECommittee ToR and membership 2018-19 (317.5kB) 18-19 CQAE 027 CMVM UG External Examiner Report statistics 2017-18ClosedDocument not published: Personal information the disclosure of which would breach the data protection principles of the Data Protection Act (section 38) 18-19 CQAE 028 EE comments paper UG 2017-18 (264.6kB) 18-19 CQAE 029 EMS 1 TPR Year on response (577.6kB)
8 October	Agenda - CQAE 8 October 2018 (250.7kB)	18-19 CQAE 10 SQAC-SubGroupReport2017-18ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 11 Good Practice from School QA ReportsClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 12 School Annual Quality Reports - College and University actionsClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 13 UpdateOnUniversityCollegeActionsClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 14 NSS Report 2018 Edinburgh Medical School (4)ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 15 NSS Report 2018 Deanery of Biomedical Sciences (2)ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 16 NSS Report 2018 Royal (Dick) School of Veterinary StudiesClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 17 Edinburgh Medical School 2018 PTES resultsClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 18 Deanery of Clinical Sciences 2018 PTES resultsClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 19 results Deanery of Biomedical Sciences 2018 PTES resultsClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 2 Action status report 17 May 2018 meetingClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 20 Deanery of Molecular, Genetic and Population Health Sciences 2018 PTES resultsClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 21 Royal (Dick) School of Veterinary Studies 2018 PTES resultsClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 22 External Examiner approval proposal v2ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 23 CMVM quarterly complaints report May 2017 to July 2018ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 3 CMVM College QAECommittee ToR and membership 2018-19 v2 (367.1kB) 18-19 CQAE 4 EMS annual quality report 2018ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 5 DBMS Quality Report 17 18ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 6 DCS QA 2018ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 7 DMGPHS annual QA Report 2017-18ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 8 Vet School Annual QAE report August 2018 FinalClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions 18-19 CQAE 9 Annual School QA Reports - common themesClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions		18-19 CQAE 1 Minutes 17 May 2018 UNCONFIRMEDClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions
16 April		17-18 CQAE Paper 50 LTC Poster proposal (120.8kB) 17-18 CQAE Paper 51 CMVM Proposal for the approval of new UG ProgrammesClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions

2011

Date	Agenda	Papers	Notes	Minutes
8 June		2011 Report to Senatus (207.9kB)
17 February		2009-2010 QA Report MBChB (219.6kB) 2009-2010 QA Report MBChB- Appendix 2 (80.9kB) BMTO QAE report 09-10 (310.3kB) QAC report on PG 2010 14Jan11 (116.2kB) VMQAC annual report 2009-10 Final (225.3kB)

2010

Date	Agenda	Papers	Notes	Minutes
5 April		Annual Report to Senatus -2010 (274.9kB) AVMA Report (62.5kB) CMVM UG Annual Course Monitoring (61.4kB) CMVM UG External Examiner Summaries 2008-2009 (204.8kB) CMVM UG Progression 2008-2009 (392.7kB)

2009

Date	Agenda	Papers	Notes	Minutes
26 March		0708 MVM QA Report - External Examiner Summaries (185.9kB) 0708 MVM QA Report ACM Data (125.4kB) 0708 MVM QA Report Progression Data (415.7kB) Annual Report to Senatus -2009 (249.9kB)
4 February	February 2009 Agenda (52.7kB)	Annex D (299.9kB) Annex E (910.2kB) BMTO QAE report 07-08 (324.1kB) BMTO Report Review (50.7kB) CMVM-PG-Review (71.2kB) MBCHB Report Review (55.3kB) PG QA-QE report 4 Feb 2009 (63kB) QAC report on PG 2007-8 (111.6kB) VMQAC annual report 2007-08 (277.5kB)		February 09 Minute (77.3kB)

2008

Date	Agenda	Papers	Notes	Minutes
6 November	October 2008 Agenda (47.1kB)	CPD QA SvH (3MB) Feedback from FY1 Doctors in South East Scotland (42kB) FY Survey (38.9kB) FY Survey App2 (29.5kB)		October 08 Minute (92.7kB)
11 June	June 2008 Agenda (72.7kB)	SUGSC ELIR Follow Up (43.5kB)		June 08 Minute (61.4kB)
18 March		Annual Report to Senatus -2008 (267.8kB) CMVM BVM and S MBChB ACM Reports 2006-2007 (53.2kB) CMVM UG EE Reports 2006-2007 (119.8kB) CMVM UG Progression Data 2006-2007 (315.4kB)
6 February	February 2008 Agenda (48.6kB)	2006 7 MBChB QA report final draft 071207ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions BMTO QAE report 06-07ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions FY Survey App3 (43kB) QA-QE report on PG 2006-07ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions QA-QE report on PG 2006-07 ANNEX BClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions VMQAC annual report 2006-07 FinalClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions		February 08 Minute (65kB)

2007

Date	Agenda	Papers	Notes	Minutes
31 October	October 2007 Agenda (44.5kB)			February 07 MinuteClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions October 07 MinuteClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions
13 June		07 Report Appendices 2 and 3 - Progression and EE summaries (959.5kB) Annual Report to Senatus -2007 (256kB)
6 February	February 2007 Agenda (48.6kB)	MBChB annual report 2005-06Draft11ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions QAQE Report BMTO 2005-06ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions VMQAC annual report 2005-06ClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions

2006

Date	Agenda	Papers	Notes	Minutes
25 October	October 2006 Agenda (44kB)	June 06Minute (59.4kB) National Student Survey stats (127.5kB) October 06 MinuteClosedDocument not published: An exemption as listed at http://www.ed.ac.uk/records-management/freedom-of-information/guidance-policies/exemptions

Last updated 17 March 2025, 2.45pm